Exceedingly Rare and Important "Made by A B CAIN 1869" Large-Sized Redware Presentation Jug, Sullivan Co, TN

Winter 2026 Auction of the Carole Wahler Collection

Lot #: 57

Estimate: $6,000-$10,000. About Estimates   About Shipping

Minimum Bid: $1,500.

An estimate is an expected selling price for an item at auction. The price ranges for each lot are considered conservative in value, and are listed as a courtesy to our bidders to give them an idea of how much they may be expected to pay to win the item. It is entirely possible for an item to sell for less or more than the given estimate.

×

Unlike almost every major auction house in the country, we handle our own shipping in-house. We understand how frustrating it can be to have to work with third-party shippers to have your objects delivered to you. Meanwhile, we also understand how important it is for you to receive your objects safely. We have over 40 years of experience safely packing antique ceramics. By default your invoice will include a shipping total via UPS Ground; you can also, of course, pick up objects at our gallery. Please feel free to contact us if you would like a quote. (A very few lots will have notes at the end of their descriptions letting you know that the object is too big or fragile for us to handle shipping ourselves.)

×

◀︎ Back to Catalog

Winter 2026 Auction Catalog

◀︎ Back to Catalog

Login

Bidding opens Wednesday, January 21, at 10am eastern. In the meantime, please feel free to browse the catalog; if you plan on bidding and haven't yet Created an Account, you can do so here. (How the auction works.)

Exceedingly Rare and Important Large-Sized Redware Presentation Jug, Inscribed "M A CAIN / Jug Maid(sic) / by A B CAIN 1869," Abraham B. Cain at the Cain Pottery, Sullivan County, TN, circa 1840-1880, highly-ovoid jug with footed base, wide, tooled mouth, ribbed handle with triply-depressed terminal, and shoulder decorated with incised with wavy combing between two horizontal lines. Incised in script below the handle with the presentation inscription, "M A CAIN / Jug Maid(sic) / by A B CAIN 1869." Surface covered in a sporadic lead-based glaze, possibly tinted with iron. One of only a few signed examples of Cain pottery known, this iconic work was made by Abraham B. Cain for his nephew, Martin A. Cain, possibly as a wedding gift for the latter's marriage in October of 1869. Its highly unusual inscription places it among the most significant examples of Sullivan County, Tennessee pottery to be documented. Exhibited: Made in East Tennessee: Pottery, Museum of East Tennessee History, 1996; Tennessee Turned, Earthenware and Stoneware Made in East Tennessee 1800-1900, Museum of East Tennessee History, May 16-October 30, 2011. Literature: Illustrated in Great Road Style: The Decorative Arts Legacy of Southwest Virginia and Northeast Tennessee, p. 134. Illustrated in Wahler, Tennessee Turned, Earthenware and Stoneware Made in East Tennessee 1800-1900, Part One, p. 150, fig. 164 and p. 220, fig. 164. Provenance: In her notes, Wahler states the following about this jug: "Another great messenger from the past. I believe this jug was made for Martin on the occasion of his marriage." A note written by Wahler that is attached to the jug reads, "Brian Cullity bought this Presentation Jug on his way out of Tennessee years ago. He sold it and a small Cain jar to the Stradlings. He was able to buy them back for me for the 1996 pottery exhibit. It is a very rare piece of TN pottery. I had the rim repaired and the crack around the base minimized in 2009. Exhibited again in 2011 in Tennessee Turned. Should probably be in a museum on(?) restoration. 'M A CAIN jug Maid[sic] by A B CAIN 1869.' " Profuse spalling and/or wear to glaze. The glaze was applied in an incomplete, splashed fashion, leaving unglazed areas to surface, as-made. A small amount of professional restoration to spout. Professional restoration, primarily only coloring, to a long horizontal crack at base. A few minor base chips. H 15 1/2".



©2026 Crocker Farm, Inc. | info@crockerfarm.com | (410) 472-2016